Discussion about this post

User's avatar
yelhat's avatar

It feels really weird how you just uncritically talk about the wool industry. You also take it for granted that sheep need to keep being bred and shorn by humans. Their lives are not this idyllic romantic painting of the humble shepherd alone in a pasture, but one where their lives are only worth as much as their wool. Lambs are mutilated, and males castrated in horrific ways. The industry norm is speed over any care of the sheep and this is all completely unnecessary. You rightfully question how ethical human hair can be, but when it comes to animal welfare it's a footnote and written off as "some" rather than the industry as a whole.

Being the mouthpiece for propaganda about commodification of these animals is certainly a strange role to elect for yourself. They are not getting small cutting nicks, but large strips of their skin, their tail, and ears are removed during this process. Shearers punch the animals and stomp them into position. Sheep consistently get broken bones from how brutal the shearers are.

Though I guess Clara Parkes is right. It's truly the vegans who are unethical. What can we do but to shear the sheep? We certainly cannot stop breeding them because that might make us choose other materials, and that would be disastrous financially.

There is no way to ethically obtain wool.

Expand full comment
Felicity's avatar

I had to return to this episode recently as I was reading the book "Life Ceremony" Sayaka Murata. Not knowing what exactly I signed up for reading the book, when the first short story opened with the main character wearing a sweater of human hair, I instantly thought of this episode! I was like wow this is so cool they know about this. The story then takes a more surreal turn with all the most expensive and high quality products in this world being made from human materials. They talk about bone tables or engagement rings. In the context of the world of the book, this is simply what is done with bodies after they die. The whole book is rather disturbing and bizzare and a bit introspective too, but I think it was quite funny how unprepared I was for the turn it would take because this episode had me less weirded out by the idea of human hair clothes then I might've otherwise

Expand full comment
18 more comments...

No posts